Technical solutions for selecting an option for replacing overaged boiler steam drums

This work investigates possible options for replacing the main separator of steam power boilers to ensure their maximal service life. Separators of drum-type boilers are reviewed in terms of their advantages and disadvantages. An analysis of two steels – WB36 and 16GNMA – is carried out by comparing their performance characteristics, chemical composition, and welding procedures. Possible technical solutions for replacing overaged drum boilers are analyzed from the technical and economic perspectives. Three options were selected for replacing the separator: a similar drum made of imported grade WB36 steel; an alternative option with a small drum and a bank of off-mounted cyclones; a drumless option based on a multi-stage evaporation cycle and a bank of cyclones. The materials currently used in separators, i.e., 16GNM and 16GNMA, are compared with imported WB36 steel. It was found that each option had its own advantages and disadvantages, which should be analyzed according to the following parameters: weight and dimensions; assumed need in lifting equipment; hydraulic losses; assumed changes in automatic boiler equipment; relative costs associated with designing, analysis, and risk management. Therefore, the presented recommendations for selecting a drum replacement option are essential for extending the service life and ensuring the reliable and safe operation of boiler equipment.

1. Zrojchikov N.A., Gorburov D.V. Comprehensive justification for expired service life drum replacement. Radioelektronika, elektrotekhnika i energetika: tezisy dokladov XVII Mezhdunarodnoj nauchno-tekhnicheskoj konferencii studentov i aspirantov = Radioelectronics, electrical engineering and power engineering: report abstracts of the 17th International scientific and technical conference of students and postgraduate students. 2 March 2017, Moscow. Mos-cow: Moscow Power Engineering Institute; 2011, vol. 3, р. 98. (In Russ.).

2. Baidakova N.V., Afonin A.V., Blagochinnov A.V. Devel-opment of an implementation algorithm of CHP steam boiler and turbine repair program based on technical condition of power equipment. Nadezhnost' i bezopasnost' energetiki = Safety and Reliability of Power Industry. 2021;14(1):40-44. (In Russ.). https://doi.org/10.24223/1999-5555-2021-14-1-40-44.

3. Popov A.B. On service life limits of power equipment. Energetik. 2021;2:8-14. (In Russ.). https://doi.org/10.34831/EP.2021.18.78.002.

4. Fedorov A.I., Petrov I.P., Tobol' D.A. Analysis of the in-fluence of inter-boiler device design and state on drum boiler operation reliability. Elektricheskie stantsii. 2006;6:65-73. (In Russ.).

5. Larkin I.S., Ovchinnikova S.M. An analysis of separation principles in boilers in terms of energy efficiency. Ogarev-Online. 2014;23. Available from: https://cyberleninka.ru/ar-ticle/n/analiz-printsipov-separatsii-v-kotloagregatah-s-tochki-zreniya-energeticheskoy-effektivnosti [Accessed 12th March 2022]. (In Russ.).

6. Moldareeva M.D. Review of separation devices for drum boilers. In: Radioelektronika, elektrotekhnika i energetika: tezisy dokladov XXVII Mezhdunarodnoj nauchno-tekhnich-eskoj konferencii studentov i aspirantov = Radioelectronics, electrical engineering and power engineering: report ab-stracts of the 27th International scientific and technical conference of students and postgraduate students. 11–12 March 2021, Moscow. Moscow: Raduga; 2021, р. 877. (In Russ.).

7. Mynkin K.P. Separation devices of steam boilers. Mos-cow: Energiya; 1971, 192 р. (In Russ.).

8. Buznikov E.F. Cyclone separators in steam boilers. Mos-cow: Energiya; 1969, 248 р. (In Russ.).

9. Lanin A.A., D'yakov Yu.G., Reva V.V. The effect of welding technology on the brittle strength of high-pressure drums. Energetik. 2018;4:14-17. (In Russ.).

10. Sultanov M.M., Baidakova N.V., Afonin A V. Analysis of the technical condition of the equipment of generating sys-tems. In: Materials Science and Engineering: IOP Conference Series. 2020;1035:012004. https://doi.org/10.1088/1757-899X/1035/1/012004.

11. Grin E.A. Brittle fractures of the drums of high-pressure boilers: main causes and methods for preventing them Teploenergetika = Thermal Engineering. 2008;2:40-45. (In Russ.).

12. Makhutov N.A. Deformation criteria of destruction and strength calculation of structural elements. Moscow: Mash-inostroenie; 1981, 272 р. (In Russ.).

13. Grin E.A., Anokhov A.E., Zelenskii A.B., Fedina I.V. Studying the metal of steam boiler drums made of grade 16GNM steel after its long-term operation. Teploenergetika = Thermal Engineering. 2010;6:37-42. (In Russ.).

14. Ozhigov L.S., Mitrofanov A.S., Tolstolutskaya G.D., Vasilenko R.L., Rudenko A.G., Ruzhytskyi V.V., et al. Comprehensive investigation of the metal in drums of boilers at thermal power stations. Teploenergetika = Thermal Engi-neering. 2017;5:40-47. (In Russ.). https://doi.org/10.1134/S004036361705006X.

15. Sultanov M.M., Bajdakova N.V., Afonin A.V. Analysis of the technical condition assessment of generating system equipment. Al'ternativnaya i intellektual'naya energetika: materialy II Mezhdunarodnoj nauchno-prakticheskoj kon-ferencii = Alternative and intelligent power engineering: materials of the 2nd International scientific and practical conference. 16–18 September 2020. Voronezh, Voronezh State Technical University; 2020;312-313. (In Russ.).

16. Kosinov Yu.P., Romanov A.A., Trofimov Yu. V. Improving power equipment repair to ensure its reliable operation beyond the fleet life and service life. Trigeneratsiya. Avail-able from: http://www.combienergy.ru/stat/691-Sovershenstvovanie-remontaenergeticheskogo-oborudovaniya [Accessed 12th March 2022]. (In Russ.).

17. Grabchak E.P. Assessment of technical condition of power equipment in digital economy. Safety and reliability of the electric power industry. 2017;10(4):268-274. https://doi.org/10.24223/1999-5555-2017-10-4-268-274.

18. Kuryanov V.N., Sultanov M.M., Kuryanova E.V., Skop-ova E.M. Mathematical model of the processes of restoration of power equipment in power systems by cri-terion of the index of technical condition. Journal of Physics: Conference Series. 2020;1683:042041. https://doi.org/10.1088/1742-6596/1683/4/042041.

19. Sultanov M.M., Tyagunov M.G., Baydakova N.V. Procedure for assessment of technical condition of equipment of generating systems taking into account control effects on the basis of data management complex of monitoring and diagnostics system. Journal of Physics Conference Series. 2020;1683(4):042035. https://doi.org/10.1088/1742-6596/1683/4/042035.

20. Kokorin E.L., Khalyasmaa A.I. Electrical equipment condition based maintenance strategy. In: International Conference and Exposition on Electrical and Power Engi-neering. 2016. https://doi.org/10.1109/ICEPE.2016.7781439.

21. Sultanov M.M., Arakelyan E.K., Shestopalova T.A., Smirnov A.A., Gorban Yu.A. Improving information support of reliability and safety of modern generating system power equipment based on Blockchain digital technology. Novoe v rossijskoj elektroenergetike. 2019;1:6-13. (In Russ.).

22. Moiseev D.O., Okhlopkov A.V. Studying operation features of steam power boilers under main separator replacement. In: Radioelektronika, elektrotekhnika i energetika: te-zisy dokladov XXVIII Mezhdunarodnoj nauchno-tekhnicheskoj konferencii studentov i aspirantov = Radio electronics, electrical engineering and energy: abstracts of the 28th International Scientific and Technical Conference of students and postgraduates. 17–19 March 2022, Moscow, Moscow: Raduga; 2022, p. 705. (In Russ.).